June 22, 2024


Imagination at work

Medicare Advantage, consolidation drove healthcare insurer trends in 2021

Photo: FG Trade/Getty Illustrations or photos

It was challenging to predict pattern lines for the payer and health insurance plan business in 2021, mostly for the reason that of persistent uncertainties due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Client habits has turn into more unpredictable, treatment versions and choices are shifting and payers are adapting to a world that is evolving speedily and in unforeseen approaches.

Just one aspect that has been rendered incredibly unpredictable by the virus is the economical health of the nation’s significant insurers, which soared during the preliminary waves of the pandemic in 2020 but then settled back down to earth towards the stop of that 12 months. In 2021, insurers continue to posted typically considerable income, but they ended up far from the heights witnessed the prior 12 months.

Around the program of the 12 months a few standard themes started out to arise. Insurers are plowing forward with digital transformation initiatives, such as the growth of telehealth and virtual health. Synthetic intelligence and machine studying have labored their way into the combine and fifty percent of payers now have innovation labs in the belief that digital innovation will be the vital to the upcoming.

Insurers also continued to consolidate in 2021, resulting in remarkably concentrated marketplaces that have drawn the attention of the federal govt, which seeks to control consolidation in a bid to empower shoppers.

And then you can find Medicare Benefit, which carries on to expand it really is believed MA programs will cover more people today in 2022 than primary Medicare. Many significant insurers have taken discover, increasing their MA choices in an effort and hard work to capture more of the industry.

It really is been a wildly different 12 months in the payer area, but the way it has performed out suggests a lot of of these pattern lines might keep on into 2022 … and outside of.


COVID-19 carries on to impact each and every aspect of American life and the healthcare business, and it really is driving developments in the payer world as properly. At the HIMSS Condition of Health care function in June, Shreesh Tiwari, principal at ZS, claimed the coronavirus has led to an improve in payer adoption of technology and innovation.

Sixty-4 % of health insurance plan executives report an accelerated adoption of digital health initiatives these kinds of as virtual health. Another 53% report an acceleration in adoption of synthetic intelligence and machine studying procedures, whilst 42% claimed COVID-19 has served aid the adoption of benefit-primarily based treatment preparations, in accordance to Condition of Health care study by HIMSS, the guardian firm of Health care Finance Information.

COVID-19 has served to push alterations not just in technology, but in mindset, Tiwari claimed. The psychological and cultural limitations in terms of adoption are no more time becoming witnessed as concerns.

All over fifty percent of payers have an innovation lab and consider AI and machine studying will push innovation forward. But 53% consider healthcare startups will direct the way in driving big technology innovation, Tiwari claimed.

The govt also performs a vital part. Forty-6 % of payers feel latest guidelines and laws will aid innovation.

“Payers have tasted the fruits of innovation in the earlier few months,” Tiwari claimed at the time. “Interoperability is becoming witnessed as a vital driver in terms of taking care of concerns coming out of the technology infrastructure, information infrastructure concerns we have, intently followed by information privateness and information security.”

Not all of insurers’ digital initiatives are likely flawlessly, nevertheless. Overall health programs are revamping their digital choices in a bid to make sure you shoppers, but these initiatives are challenging, a Deloitte survey discovered in June. Numerous programs are having difficulties to effectively prioritize initiatives, suggesting a absence of crystal clear vision.

In simple fact, about fifty percent of the 35 technology leaders surveyed discovered this absence of vision as an impediment to these ongoing digital transformation initiatives. 

Consumers are the ones mostly afflicted, as client-dealing with platforms have created the the very least development. A very little around fifty percent of respondents, 57%, claimed they are continue to in the procedure of advancing these programs, whilst the remainder have not nevertheless started out but say they will do so within just the up coming two many years.

There are other regions that are lagging as properly. The survey focused on modernization initiatives of 5 technology platforms – administrative, analytics, clinical, main, client support and engagement – and only two respondents claimed they had modernized just one of those people platforms.

These surveyed discovered cyber and details security as the quantity two investment decision priority soon after organization intelligence. But they warned it could be pricey to suitable cyber-related errors, particularly ones acquiring to do with cloud configuration. Baking in cybersecurity in DevOps from the outset could make for a more effective and resilient procedure.

The findings converse to the broader challenge of affected person engagement, which has been an ongoing situation for health programs and insurers. A J.D. Electrical power 2020 U.S. Business Member Overall health System analyze discovered that 60% of privately insured U.S. health approach members claimed they had not been contacted by their health approach with assistance or details related to COVID-19, and virtually fifty percent (48%) claimed their health approach has not demonstrated problem for their health due to the fact the pandemic commenced.

Overall health programs have not acquired client centricity, as just 36% of commercial health approach members claimed their health approach functions in their greatest desire “often” or “most of the time,” and just 25% claimed they look at their health approach as a reliable lover in their health and wellness.

This absence of client-centric positioning resulted in an general gratification score final 12 months for commercial health programs of 719 on a one,000-position scale, among the the most affordable of all industries evaluated, in accordance to J.D. Electrical power.

THE Increase OF MEDICARE Benefit

Medicare Benefit enrollment continued to improve and a number of significant insurers expanded their MA footprints. It really is turn into a hot industry for insurers heading into the new 12 months.

The Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Providers claimed that in 2022, MA is projected to reach 29.five million people today when compared to 26.9 million enrolled in a Medicare Benefit approach in 2021. 

For a lot of seniors, MA is the desired health insurance plan for the reason that of its minimal upfront every month costs and additional positive aspects. Medicare Benefit programs will keep on to present a large range of supplemental positive aspects in 2022, such as eyewear, hearing aids, both preventive and in depth dental positive aspects, accessibility to meals (for a constrained period), around-the-counter merchandise, exercise positive aspects and around the globe emergency/urgent protection. 

In addition, the proportion of programs presenting exclusive supplemental positive aspects for chronically unwell persons will improve from 19% to 25%.

An increasing quantity of Medicare Benefit twin suitable exclusive wants programs cover both Medicare and Medicaid solutions for people today who are dually suitable. In 2022, 295 programs (when compared to 256 in 2021), will cover all Medicare solutions, moreover Medicaid-included behavioral health therapy or extended-term solutions.

CMS will keep on to test the Part D Senior Savings Design for insulin for seniors in more than 2,a hundred programs in 2022. This 12 months, around five hundred new Medicare Benefit and Part D prescription drug programs, as properly as two new pharmaceutical producers of insulin, are becoming a member of the design that reduces out-of-pocket shelling out.

Also, more than one,000 Medicare Benefit programs will participate in the CMS Innovation Center’s Medicare Benefit Value-Primarily based Insurance policies Design and style Design in 2022, which tests the impact of presenting a projected 3.7 million people today personalized positive aspects intended to superior handle their ailments and handle social wants from food insecurity to social isolation. 

The VBID Model’s Hospice Benefit Ingredient, now in its second 12 months, will also be presented by 115 Medicare Benefit programs in parts of 22 states and U.S. territories. It offers enrollees amplified accessibility to palliative and built-in hospice treatment. 

To help with their Medicare costs, minimal-revenue seniors and adults with disabilities might qualify to get economical guidance from the Medicare Savings Plans. Only about fifty percent of suitable people today are enrolled, CMS claimed.

Cigna is obtaining on on the act by increasing its MA programs, escalating into 108 new counties and a few new states – Connecticut, Oregon and Washington – which will improve its geographic presence by virtually thirty%, the insurance company claimed in Oct.

As element of the growth, Cigna claimed most latest prospects will fork out the same or lower rates, and promised that each and every industry will have at the very least just one $ premium approach. Other positive aspects will include things like a social connection program to beat loneliness, personalized programs for people today with diabetic issues and incentives for once-a-year wellness tests and other preventive treatment.

Cigna has amplified its geographic presence in MA by eighty% due to the fact 2019, the insurance company claimed. The firm now gives programs in 477 counties throughout 26 states and the District of Columbia.

Centene, in the meantime, claimed this 12 months it will be broadening its reach in the Medicare Benefit area in 2022, increasing into 327 new counties and a few new states: Massachusetts, Nebraska and Oklahoma.

In all, this signifies a 26% growth of Centene’s MA footprint, with the presenting readily available to a possible 48 million beneficiaries throughout 36 states. At present, Centene serves more than one.one million MA members throughout 33 states.

In September, Centene also declared it would consolidate its latest Medicare manufacturers, such as Allwell, Overall health Internet, Fidelis Treatment, Trillium Benefit, ‘Ohana Overall health System and TexanPlus, under just one unified brand dubbed Wellcare.

Meanwhile, UnitedHealthcare, which currently has sizeable industry regulate with its Medicare Benefit programs, will fortify its foothold in the area by increasing its MA programs in 2022, introducing a possible 3.one million members and achieving ninety four% of Medicare-suitable shoppers in the U.S.

At present, more than 7.3 million people today are currently enrolled in UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare Benefit programs. The insurance company claimed the growth will concentration on reducing prescription drug costs, and strengthening positive aspects and the member practical experience.

But whilst UnitedHealthcare has a huge foothold in the Medicare Benefit area, it underwent scrutiny from the federal govt before this month, when the Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Providers blocked 4 Medicare Benefit programs from enrolling new members in 2022 for the reason that they did not devote the bare minimum threshold on health-related positive aspects. Three UnitedHealthcare programs and just one Anthem approach unsuccessful to strike the demanded eighty five% mark a few many years in a row.

Medicare Benefit programs are demanded to devote a bare minimum of eighty five% of premium bucks on health-related costs failure to do so for a few consecutive many years triggers the sanctions.

For UHC, the penalties utilize to its MA programs in Arkansas, New Mexico and the Midwest, which encompasses Missouri, Kansas, Nebraska and Iowa. UHC programs cover about 83,000 members, and the Anthem approach covers about one,two hundred members. They simply cannot present pick programs to members right up until 2023, assuming they strike the eighty five% threshold up coming 12 months – what is identified as the health-related decline ratio (MLR). If they fall short to strike the threshold for 5 many years in a row, the govt will terminate the contracts.

UHC associates advised Bloomberg that it missed the eighty five% benchmark in specific marketplaces in element for the reason that of people deferring health-related treatment due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Humana also declared it would debut a new Medicare Benefit PPO approach in 37 rural counties in North Carolina in response to industry demand from customers in the eastern element of the point out. 


Overall health insurance company consolidation has been a different ongoing pattern – and just one the latest administration would like to see with tighter reigns.

An govt purchase issued by President Joe Biden in July cracked down on healthcare facility and health insurance plan consolidations and other steps it claimed decreases competitors and drives up charges. The 4 regions of healthcare focused are: prescription medication, healthcare facility consolidation, health insurance plan consolidations and hearing aids.

Consolidation in the health insurance plan business has meant that a lot of shoppers have very little selection when it will come to picking insurers, the purchase claimed. 

Biden directed the Department of Overall health and Human Providers to standardize approach selections in the health insurance plan market so people today can comparison shop more easily. Programs presented on the exchanges are challenging by the different solutions presented and dissimilarities in deductibles, the purchase claimed.

Rick Pollack, president and CEO of the American Healthcare facility Affiliation, urged federal organizations at the time to concentration on guidelines that handle competitors among the commercial health insurers.

“In simple fact, with commercial health insurance plan programs, virtually a few out of 4 marketplaces ended up remarkably concentrated in 2019 and the top rated 5 greatest insurers alone regulate virtually fifty% of the industry. Research have discovered that when an insurance plan industry is remarkably concentrated, insurers lower provider payments and do not go financial savings alongside to the client.”

The results of consolidation in 2021 also prolonged to prescription medication. Consolidation among the standalone Medicare Part D prescription drug programs was the root induce of a 23% decline in choices for 2022, in accordance to findings posted final month by the Kaiser Relatives Basis.

The ordinary Medicare beneficiary will have a selection of 23 stand-alone prescription drug programs (PDPs) in 2022, seven much less PDP selections than in 2021, the information showed. Even though the quantity of PDP selections in 2022 is far lower than the peak in 2007 – when there ended up fifty six these kinds of selections, on ordinary – there are continue to numerous standalone drug approach selections, in accordance to KFF.

The rather large lessen in the quantity of PDPs for 2022 is largely the result of consolidations of approach choices sponsored by Cigna and Centene, resulting in the industry exit of a few nationwide PDPs from every company in every location: all a few of Cigna’s Categorical Scripts PDPs and a few of Centene’s 6 Wellcare PDPs. Part D sponsors are constrained to presenting no more than a few PDPs in every location. 

This accounts for just around two hundred PDPs presented in 2021 that will no more time be presented in 2022. Enrollees in these consolidated programs will be quickly switched to other programs presented by the same approach sponsor, whilst they can pick to switch into a different approach during the once-a-year open up enrollment time period.

The quantity of companies sponsoring stand-alone drug programs has declined steadily around time, from more than 40 companies in 2010 and before many years, dropping underneath 25 companies commencing in 2015, and at sixteen companies in 2022. That is lower than in any other 12 months due to the fact Part D started out. 

PDP enrollment is anticipated to be concentrated in a little quantity of companies in 2022, as it has been each and every 12 months. Primarily based on August 2021 enrollment, 8 out of 10 enrollees in 2022 are projected to be in PDPs operated by just 4 companies: CVS Overall health, Centene, UnitedHealth and Humana. All 4 companies present PDPs in all 34 regions up coming 12 months.

Despite these 12 months-to-12 months alterations in approach protection and costs, as properly as alterations in beneficiaries’ health wants, a prior KFF examination discovered that most Medicare beneficiaries did not review programs during a the latest open up enrollment time period, and most Part D enrollees did not review the protection presented by their drug approach to other drug programs.

The quantities are similar throughout both Medicare Benefit and regular Medicare, with sixty eight% of MA beneficiaries stating they really don’t review health-related programs, and 73% of those people in regular Medicare claiming the same.

Twitter: @JELagasse
E-mail the writer: [email protected]